More Panera Bread Guides
Discover more helpful guides and insider tips for your Panera Bread dining experience.
12 Hidden Items You Can Order Right Now
Panera does not advertise a secret menu. But their customization engine is wide open — and once you know the right combinations, you can build items that outperform the standard menu in taste and value. These 12 off-menu orders are built using ingredients already in every Panera kitchen.
12
Hidden Items
App
Order Via
$0–$3
Extra Cost
100%
Orderable
Every item below can be built in the Panera app under "Customize"
Start with a regular Broccoli Cheddar bread bowl ($7.98). Add bacon ($1.49) and extra cheddar ($0.79). The bacon crumbles sink into the hot soup and the extra cheese makes it noticeably thicker. It is the single most popular off-menu order among Panera regulars and it turns a good soup into a genuinely indulgent meal.
How to Build:
Broccoli Cheddar Bread Bowl → Customize → Add Bacon → Add Extra Cheddar Cheese
Start with the Mediterranean Bowl with Chicken ($9.99). Add avocado ($1.29) and an extra portion of chicken ($1.00). You end up with a bowl pushing 45g+ protein. The avocado adds a creamy texture that balances the lemon tahini dressing. This is the post-gym meal that Panera does not know they are selling.
How to Build:
Mediterranean Bowl w/ Chicken → Customize → Add Avocado → Add Extra Chicken
Start with the regular Grilled Cheese ($7.49). Add bacon ($1.49) and tomato ($0.79). The bacon adds crunch and salt, the tomato adds moisture and acidity. It turns a plain grilled cheese into something that actually competes with the full sandwich lineup. Pair it with a cup of Cream of Tomato for the ultimate comfort combo.
How to Build:
Grilled Cheese → Customize → Add Bacon → Add Tomato
Start with the Chipotle Chicken Avocado Melt ($8.89). Add pepper jack cheese ($0.99) and jalapenos ($0.29). The chipotle sauce already brings heat, but the pepper jack and fresh jalapenos push it into legitimately spicy territory. If you think Panera is too mild, this build fixes that.
How to Build:
Chipotle Chicken Avo Melt → Customize → Swap to Pepper Jack → Add Jalapenos
Fill your cup halfway with Strawberry Lemon Mint Charged Lemonade, then top it off with regular lemonade. The result is a lighter, less sweet version of the Charged Lemonade with a pale pink color. It cuts the intensity of the full Charged Lemonade while keeping the caffeine boost. The self-serve station makes this a zero-cost upgrade.
How to Build:
Self-serve station → Half Strawberry Lemon Mint Charged Lemonade → Half Regular Lemonade
Order a Cinnamon Crunch Bagel ($1.89) with a side of cream cheese ($1.99). Slice it open and spread the cream cheese thick. The sweet cinnamon crunch topping against the tangy cream cheese creates a flavor combination that tastes like a dessert. It is the cheapest and most satisfying secret menu item on this list.
How to Build:
Cinnamon Crunch Bagel → Add Cream Cheese Spread
Order a Broccoli Cheddar Bread Bowl ($7.98) and a side cup of Cream of Tomato ($2.29 as a side in You Pick Two). Pour the tomato soup on top of the cheddar soup inside the bread bowl. The two soups layer together and create a tomato-cheddar hybrid that is richer than either one alone. It sounds weird. It works.
How to Build:
Broccoli Cheddar Bread Bowl + Side Cup of Cream of Tomato → Pour tomato into bread bowl
Caesar Salad with Chicken → remove lettuce → add in a warm ciabatta roll on the side. Stuff the chicken and Caesar dressing into the roll yourself. DIY chicken Caesar sandwich for $2 less than the sandwich menu.
Asiago Cheese Bagel + Scrambled Egg + Tomato + Extra Cheese. Tastes like a breakfast pizza on a bagel base. Ask them to toast it open-faced for the best texture.
Green Goddess Cobb Salad + extra chicken + avocado. Skip the greens and request it as a bowl. You get a protein-heavy plate that hits 50g+ protein with the avocado fat to slow digestion.
Mac & Cheese in a Bread Bowl ($7.98) + bacon ($1.49). The mac is thick enough that it stays inside the bread without leaking. The bread soaks up the cheese sauce on the edges. It is 1,100+ calories of pure comfort.
Half iced tea, half lemonade from the self-serve station. The classic golf-course drink, free with the Sip Club. Adjust the ratio to your taste — more tea for less sweetness, more lemonade for a citrus punch. Works with any tea flavor.
Every add-on price so you can calculate your own secret menu builds
Bacon
+$1.49
Avocado
+$1.29
Extra Chicken
+$1.00
Extra Cheese
+$0.79
Pepper Jack Swap
+$0.99
Cream Cheese
+$1.99
Tomato
+$0.79
Remove Anything
Free
Not officially. Panera does not publish a 'secret menu' like some chains. But the customization system on the app and kiosk is so flexible that you can build dozens of off-menu items by modifying existing ones. Every item in this guide can be ordered at any Panera location using the standard customization options.
Use the Panera app or in-store kiosk. Select a base item, then tap 'Customize' to add, remove, or swap ingredients. You can also tell the cashier what you want, but the app is faster and avoids miscommunication. Every modification in this guide uses ingredients already available in the system.
Some do. Adding avocado is $1.29, adding bacon is $1.49, and extra cheese is $0.79. Removing ingredients is always free. The total price depends on which base item you start with and how many additions you make. We list the approximate total for each item in the guide.
Yes. Any customized order you build in the Panera app can be sent through Rapid Pick-Up or delivery. Third-party platforms like DoorDash also support Panera customizations, but the app gives you more modification options.
The Loaded Broccoli Cheddar Bread Bowl with bacon and extra cheese is the most popular off-menu order among Panera regulars. It adds about $2.28 to the base bread bowl price but transforms it into a completely different meal. The bacon crumbles melt into the cheese and the extra cheddar makes the soup thicker.
Yes. Since these are just customized versions of regular menu items, they are available any time the base item is on the menu. That means all day for sandwiches, soups, and salads. Bakery items depend on availability.
Yes. After you customize an order, tap 'Save to Favorites' before checking out. Next time you open the app, your secret menu item is one tap away under your favorites. This is the fastest way to reorder your custom builds.
Probably not. These are community-created names, not official Panera terms. Do not walk up to the counter and say 'I want the Power Protein Bowl.' Instead, use the app to build it, or describe the modifications to the cashier step by step.
Removing items is always free. Adding premium ingredients costs extra: avocado ($1.29), bacon ($1.49), extra cheese ($0.79), extra protein ($2.49). Swapping bread types is usually free. The app shows the price adjustment in real time as you customize.
The drink station is self-serve, so you can mix your own combinations. The most popular is the 'Pink Drink' — half Strawberry Lemon Mint Charged Lemonade, half regular lemonade. It is free to mix if you have the Sip Club. There is no extra charge for mixing self-serve drinks.
Tested every build on this list at real Panera locations
Every secret menu item in this guide was personally ordered, photographed, and eaten by Marcus at multiple Panera locations. Prices are verified against the 2026 app. Customization availability is confirmed. No theoretical builds — only items that actually work when you hit "Submit Order."
Open the app. Tap Customize. Build something the menu never intended.
Discover more helpful guides and insider tips for your Panera Bread dining experience.
Share your Panera Bread experience with fellow fans!
Fetching feedback...